Thursday, March 22, 2007

EPs

So in looking through my music, I realize just how many EPs I actually own. I've also, for the time being, slotted Beirut's Lon Gisland EP into the top 5 of albums released so far this year. But how can 15 and a half minutes of music possibly stand up to the scope and diaspora of styles and themes found in a full album? (Well, one that's not released by the Shins, who seem to rerelease the same half hour album every couple years)

For some artists, the EP is a way to try new things, to tinker with a fuller band sound (Beirut) or percussion (Iron and Wine), for some it's a chance to clear out the archives (Sondre Lerche), or even just experiment with a cheesy synth riff (Architecture in Helsinki). The Flaming Lips released two of the worst EPs known to man by repackaging some remixes and one-off covers to capitalize on the expanded visibility they had with Yoshimi, whereas Colin Meloy used the EP to release (for the most part only at tour stops) his covers of Morrissey and Shirley Collins tracks (I'll be honest, the "Sings" series is the only way I'd listen to Morrissey), which ostensibly influenced him, though he followed those quite listenable EPs up with a full length Decemberists album that contained none of that folk introversion.

Anyway, I'm sure these thoughts are quite underformed, but maybe there's a poetic justic in not being able to properly talk about otherwise deserving albums, like Hello Saferide's Would You Let Me Play This EP 10 Times A Day or They Might Be Giants' Why Does The Sun Shine EP, because they themselves don't properly sit with the artists' full length releases.

1 comment:

Woodman said...

Perhaps you've over-analyzed this one? Clearly, the Flaming Lips EPs were a crime against humanity, but when done properly, I would draw the following parallels: Novel is to novella as LP is to EP.

It's unfortunate that the EP format (in its purest sense) is even more endangered than the album, because so many people abuse it. You even neglected the accidental EPs (by definition) that result from indulgent Japanese bonus tracking.

Examples of proper EPs:

Isobel Campbell - O Love Is Teasin'
Alina Simone - Prettier in the Dark
Jesca Hoop - Silverscreen Demos
Pit Er Pat - Emergency